The user wrote "The first thing . Discipline Issues, a harry potter fanfic | FanFiction He was not lying when he said one of the reasons James hated Snape was because Snape was into . Heart officially broken. Set one month after James rescues Snape from the Shrieking Shack, and from Sirius' stupidity. severus Snape helped Harry because he loved lily evans or ... 7 years ago. Snape's very first words to Harry were secretly about Lily Snape wasn't being hurt well Lily was telling James off. By Lindsay Press Published Jun 09, 2021 James Potter publicly humiliates Severus Snape Date June, 1976 How did Lily and James Potter fall in love? Did James Potter apologize to Snape, ever? - Quora Snape also rounded on James's spirited wish for a place at the Gryffindor table with the acid-tongued 'If you'd rather be brawny than brainy.' The worst of it was that, when eventually released by Potter following the O.W.L.s incident, an enraged, humiliated Snape insisted he didn't need the help of Lily, a 'filthy little Mudblood'. What did Harry first see when he looked in the mirror? Do you think Snape and Lily would end up together if it ... I promise that as soon as we are finished here, I will take you down to . "An apology is one thing", James countered, "But a date with Lily Evans is another!" "Sirius", whispered Peter, pulling him off to one side, "This might not be a bad idea. Snape's self-proclaimed love for Harry's mother became the guiding force of his actions throughout the series, and there was a portion of the book dedicated to seeing Snape's history with Lily and understanding the moral relativity that exists in even the people we think are clearly good or evil. James Potter/Severus Snape - Works | Archive of Our Own "Snape, what a pleasant surprise," James drawled the sarcastic statement. Trying to make Snape apologize, James turns him upside-down again, and as Lily walks away, James threatens to de-pants him in front of the crowd . Snape got ambushed in that fight iirc. But he's not. Harry Potter: 21 Things That Make No Sense About Snape And ... Moony is feeling a bit vengeful, and is demanding a proper apology - but not on on his own behalf. The five of them sat, Severus Snape on one end with the two professors between him and James Potter and Sirius Black. He didn't risk his life to protect Snape, but he did risk his life to protect his friends. Snape thought it over, he could just say no and leave he would be fully entitled to do, but really he wanted to get this over with too. To quote a friend of mine, "I can't believe that it's the Year of our Lord 2017 and there are still people who defend . She basically makes fun of him for playing with a snitch and making his hair look like he got off a broom. Then one day, James was making fun of Snape (again) by hanging him up by the ankle. He grew up in a happy home in which he was adored and loved, never once being given any reason to doubt that he was his parents' entire pride and joy. It seems that both Sirius and Lupin hold a degree of respect for Dumbledore, who trusts Snape. It's a position that was absolutely inexcusable considering that the Death Eaters are well known in their community now. It's explained that James was a bit of a big-headed jock, but he's never pictured as bullying anyone else but Snape (and it's clearly stated that Snape was an unlikeable creep who loved the Dark Arts). Snape was still royally pissed, so, without thinking, he said something along the lines of, "I dont need your help, Mudblood." James Potter may know Lily Evans, but they don't seem particularly close at the point where he initially tries to win her affections. (The same scene shown in the Half-Blood Prince). Snape was the only person who knew the counter curse, James could have easily died if he wasn't lucky that the curse missed. James Potter, Harry James Potter y James Sirius Potter tienen mucho más en común que llamarse James y apellidarse Potter, ya que a los tres les gusta el verde de singular manera. James beamed with delight, reveling in the attention he was receiving. Let me break it down for you. What Snape attempted to do to James looked much worse to me than what James actually did to Snape. As members of the Order of the Pheonix they have to listen to him. Dumbledore saw the need to swear Snape to secrecy after these events. Moony is feeling a bit vengeful, and is demanding a proper apology - but not on on his own behalf. If anything Snape should apologize to Lily for acting that way to a long time friend. Maraudentium. But Lilly did defend snape.in the memory of James bullying snape Lilly walks over and tell Potter off. Severus Snape is a fictional character in J. K. Rowling 's Harry Potter series. It probably started out as just a lark, with two kids just kind of flexing their muscles to see who could stand up to who, like two young rams testing the strength of their horns. Snape's first words to Harry is a hidden apology. "I'm sorry" He paused. "I'm sorry I invaded your privacy. James ruffled his hair, and drew his most charming style, Sirius looked nervously at Snape (both Snape and Lily knew why) and Remus was smiling at both of them, though fear was in his eyes as he looked at Snape. Snape calls her this when she's trying to DEFEND him from James' bullying. The user wrote "The first thing . Snape is smart and inventive, but he's not the only person in the books who invented magic spells or artifacts. It comes with the territory when you create a story as in-depth as hers, and it paid off, considering "Harry Potter" is the second biggest book and movie franchise of all time (Marvel Universe is first). Upon looking into it, Harry saw his late parents, Lily and James Potter. In fact, James had stopped hurting Snape while he was having an argument with Lily. Snape was trying to get the Marauders expelled and he focused his efforts on Remus, James's friend. Answer (1 of 11): As far as we know, No. Voldemort's voice reverberated from the walls and floor, and . We can survive a week without pranks, and honestly, it would be worth it to apologize to Snape to get James to stop constantly talking about Lily and his newest scheme to get . "Now, first of all, Mr. Snape, I apologize for not sending you straight to the Hospital Wing, but the situation is such that I need to deal with it now. Answer (1 of 7): There is no evidence that Snape was a bully. James guided Snape to the nearest bed. James didn't apologize to Severus. There was too much hate and he built James up to be everything that made his life suck. . 2. James grew up and became more kind and Lily fell in love with him. But I find it unlikely Dumbledore would treat him as callously as he did Snape. James pulled Snape out before he could come to harm. Photo: Tumblr/Warner Bros. A Tumblr user named Tom Hiddles might have figured out what we all overlooked. Harry Potter fans love to argue about the relationship between Severus Snape and Lily Potter. "Potter," Snape sneered as he got to his feet. James Potter's father, Fleamont Potter invented the "Sleekeazy's Hair Potion", which made the Potter's extremely rich, and James grew up very wealthy. They both looked shocked at this, James Potter was apologizing, and genuinely no sarcasm at all and was offering to end this with Severus. Snape fans want to think that Snape is a genius compared to the Marauders ( I will grant that Snape is a genius compared to Peter Pettigrew ), and compared to Hermione. During their years as pupils, both Snape and Lily were excellent students. Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. Sirius, a bit frightened, Lupin, like he was actually ready to apologize, and Lily, sitting their and smiling like she was telling him, "They don't bite, don't worry.'' Lily was first to stand up. When James' father died, his money passed down to James. @killers10333: If you mean that adult . There was a light that illuminated both men. Lilly came to his defense, and James, who liked Lilly, dropped Snape when she told him to. Snape's first words to Harry is a hidden apology. James was grinning, like this was all a big joke, having to apologize to old Snivellus. "Hi Evans," James said, smiling at her. No, James would never apologize to Snape. Heart officially broken. Chapter 2: the apology. While James's back is turned, Snape throws a spell at James. It has been over twenty years since Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, the first book in the series of stories about the wizard, was published. He was hanging out with people who believed Lily's very existence was an abomination. (this is not headcanon btw, you can search it up, Rowling . Later, Snape tries to apologize for calling Lily a . A Professor at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Snape is hostile to Harry due to his resemblance to his father James Potter. But honestly, even if he did, I don't think Snape would have accepted the apology. Sitting Snape shrugged James off, "Leave Potter." "You need to apologize to Evans." "Really?" Severus sneered, "Since when did you become my mother?" James took the seat across from him ignoring Sirius waving for his attention. Set one month after James rescues Snape from the Shrieking Shack, and from Sirius' stupidity. Snape did everything for Lily's sake.Snape never liked Harry.And for Snape, however he might have tried to find Lily in Harry, all he would have found was James.Even though deep down by heart Harry was like is mother as Dumbledore said, his appearance and his behavior was more like that of James and Sirius. James, as you may have guessed, was a jerk, and didnt even make amends with Vernon Dursley after a double date. Remus Lupin had his nose buried in a book once again. "You called her a Mudblood." "Its the truth." Snape snarled, "Mudbloods are . Legacies like "Harry's mother," "James Potter's wife," and — most prominently — "the woman that Severus Snape loved and died for". James was entirely blameless in that incident, and didn't have to get involved. Harry remained kneeling at Snape's side, simply staring down at him, until quite suddenly a high, cold voice spoke so close to them that Harry jumped on his feet, the flask gripped tightly in his hands, thinking that Voldemort had reentered the room. It was Snape who brought James' attention back to him by slicing James' cheek open.) Lily had a little twitch so she deserved to be called mudblood. Meanwhile Snape invented or figured out the Sectumsempra curse to use on James and Sirius because he would've hurt other people if Lily hadn't died. 3. level 2. James was his . James said offering his hand to Snape to shake. When Snape made no move to speak, he continued. He is an exceptionally skilled wizard whose sarcastic, controlled exterior conceals deep emotions and anguish. And it's not exactly out of character - in the Prince's potion book, he wrote "Sectumsempra, for enemies". Old snape is likely much better than young potter, simply due to experience. T. She makes James stop bullying snape until snape says I don't need help from a filthy mud blood. It is, I have noticed, not terribly uncommon among the readers of Harry Potter to characterize Severus Snape solely as a hero - on account of his arduous, painful, and extremely important work in defeating Voldemort, and James Potter as merely a lousy, no-good, jerk - on account of his teenage tendency to bully people (especially Snape). James Potter publicly humiliates Severus Snape Date June, 1976 He turned to Snape, smile and charm gone. Let me break it down for you. Steeling himself, he muttered to Ron and . During school, James was probably firmly convinced that Severus "deserved" what he got. Answer (1 of 21): No, although his doing so wasn't the issue so much as it was a symptom of just how far into the Dark Arts and into the Junior Death Eaters he had fallen into. RELATED: Harry Potter: 10 Worst Things The Ministry Of Magic Did To Harry Peter Pettigrew was obviously too far gone to ever be redeemed, which left Remus as the Marauder who was remorseful. James retaliates by hanging Snape upside down in the air, "his robes falling over his head to reveal skinny, pallid legs and a pair of greying underpants" (28.247). "Snape." he said. Snape and Lily were more into the finer elements of magic, while James and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders. J.K. Rowling has to take responsibility for killing off quite a few lovable characters throughout the "Harry Potter" series. It is, I have noticed, not terribly uncommon among the readers of Harry Potter to characterize Severus Snape solely as a hero - on account of his arduous, painful, and extremely important work in defeating Voldemort, and James Potter as merely a lousy, no-good, jerk - on account of his teenage tendency to bully people (especially Snape). It is, I have noticed, not terribly uncommon among the readers of Harry Potter to characterize Severus Snape solely as a hero - on account of his arduous, painful, and extremely important work in defeating Voldemort, and James Potter as merely a lousy, no-good, jerk - on account of his teenage tendency to bully people (especially Snape). J.K . Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. Did James Potter ever apologize to Snape? But as he wants to look into Harry's eyes because they are the . James and Sirius and Hermione all demonstrated . Why did James Potter hate Snape? Why did James Potter spend all those years at Hogwarts pushing Severus Snape around, and did James know Severus was in love with Lily Evans at the time? With James he might suggest and otherwise manipulate in order to gain as much for the war effort. Snape's self-proclaimed love for Harry's mother became the guiding force of his actions throughout the series, and there was a portion of the book dedicated to seeing Snape's history with Lily and understanding the moral relativity that exists in even the people we think are clearly good or evil. James glanced at Sirius then to Snape. But he never apologized. James looked the exact same as the day he had died. Harry Potter: 10 Reasons Severus Snape Doesn't Deserve Redemption Severus Snape may have done a few decent things in his life, but did this Harry Potter character really deserve full redemption? Snape, Lily, James, and Sirius were in some ways prodigies in their own rights. As he matured as with age after school, he could have been not proud of it like Sirius. 2. level 2. Make no mistake: Severus Snape did not die for Lily Evans . Snape would have had to have openly rejected the wannabe Death-Eater crowd he was hanging around with, for Lily to have considered resuming her friendship with him. . Alan Sidney Patrick Rickman (21 February 1946 - 14 January 2016) was an English actor and director. "LEAVE HIM ALONE!" Lily Evans was back, her eyes blazing with rage and indignation. James Potter and Severus Snape are very different and yet very similar. Although he didn't apologize to the people he hurt, Remus at least turned over a new leaf and never got involved in such behavior again. James Potter loved Lily more. In his attempt to stay hidden from Argus Filch, the school caretaker, he stumbled upon the classroom where the mirror was being stored. He did. Even a cursory review of Snape's characterization just doesn't allow for that kind of sentimentality. At the same ages, james was always better. Harry Potter fans love to argue about the relationship between Severus Snape and Lily Potter. Pero solo cuando este es portado por tres particulares y orgullosos Slytherin. "James Potter, you are disgusting!" "Not as disgusting as this." James dangled Snape's underwear in her livid face. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? And as impossible . They also likely, having been around when Snape spent days trying to apologize to Lily, have some insight into why Snape became a spy upon Lily's death. Immediately, the man under him tensed. Known for his deep, languid voice, he trained at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art in London and became a member of the Royal Shakespeare Company (RSC), performing in modern and classical theatre productions. 1. J.K . But he never got the chance to say what he exactly thought Harry was for the boy blurted out. The worst that we ever hear about him Sirius commenting that he 'came to Hogwarts knows more curses than anyone else' - which may not be true. Because, Then, instead of this line, > "Yeah," said Harry, "but he just attacked Snape for no good reason, just because — well, just because you said you were bored," he finished with a. I'm sorry for what my father and his friends did to you. We don't know that Lily didn't know about the "werewolf prank." As for her knowledge of Snape/James' ongoing interactions: He thought that he might wait until after he got the essay he finished back. And yet he did. Snape would never forgive James or be able to move on from hating him because he was bitterly jealous about not having Lily. James was born to a wealthy inventor, Fleamont Potter, and his loving wife. Lily shouldn't apologize for getting upset over being called a Mudblood, she has every right to be angry at Snape for calling her that at a time she was helping him. One week later, Harry received his essay with a "P" but relatively few corrections. This calls into question whether, in any language, Snape would openly reference his love for Lily to anyone, much less Harry Potter, the son of James Potter, Snape's hated enemy and the boy Lily chose over Snape. He played the Vicomte de Valmont in the RSC stage production of Les Liaisons . Given that James Potter was dead, it seemed like the best answer he could hope for. Edit: Snape's last words in the Harry Potter books were "Look at me," not the above quote which was added in for the movie. Neither did the other Marauders. Harry Potter: 7 Reasons Lily Potter Should Have Been With Snape (& 8 Why James Was The Right Choice) Lily Evans made one simple choice when she was still just a teenager that literally changed the course of wizard history in many ways. From what we know, that year produced brilliant students. That's also a load of crap. Trying to make Snape apologize, James turns him upside-down again, and as Lily walks away, James threatens to de-pants him in front of the crowd . Chapter 33: The Prince's Tale. It has been over twenty years since Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, the first book in the series of stories about the wizard, was published. But I doubt Dumbledore could or would exert as much influence over James as he did Snape. … The only person who did ever apologise after Snape's worst memory was Severus. I'm sorry I embarrassed you. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? James put Snape upside down, Lily came to his defense and Snaoe insulted her. And as impossible . It may be Sirius trying to simply justify his and James' behaviour towards Snape to Harry. 2. In this specific case, I've never thought Rowling did the dirty on James Potter. "He got off too lightly, he didn't even have to apologize to Snape" Actually, after Harry was born and Lily was pregnant with her second child she convinced James to truce with Snape and even make him the godfather of the second child. J.K. Rowling shouldn't apologize for killing garbage human Severus Snape. Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone; . Photo: Tumblr/Warner Bros. A Tumblr user named Tom Hiddles might have figured out what we all overlooked. Albus again was not that much of a positive presence in Snape's life. James was immaterial to her real disagreement with Snape. They both hated each other and were asshats to each other. From his wild untamed hair to the slightly crumpled robes, he was an exact replica of the corpse he had seen when looking for Lily. So here, we received a lot of information about the dynamic between Snape and James. Oh wait. He swallowed again, and decided to apologize to Snape. She tells James that he's "an arrogant, bullying toerag" (28.242) who should let Snape go. I don't agree with your theory. James & # x27 ; father died, his money passed down to James the... Snape attempted to do to James looked much worse to me than what James actually did Snape! He focused his efforts on remus, James had stopped hurting Snape while was. Fanfic | FanFiction < /a > but Lilly did defend snape.in the memory James. But he did risk his life to protect Snape, what did have. On remus, James had stopped hurting Snape while he was an abomination he... The memory of James bullying Snape Lilly walks over and tell Potter off stopped... Agree with your theory James up to be everything that made his suck! //Www.Fanfiction.Net/S/10322268/1/A-Sirius-Apology '' > Harry Potter: 7 reasons Lily Potter should have been not proud of it like.. Space < /a > what did Harry first see when he looked in the Half-Blood Prince.! With Vernon Dursley after a double date Snape is hostile to Harry stage! Never forgive James or be able to move on from hating him because he bitterly... I promise that as soon as we know, no protect Snape, what Harry. Este es portado por tres particulares y orgullosos Slytherin turned, Snape tries apologize! As we know, no he turned to Snape lot of information about dynamic... The mirror as callously as he matured as with age after school, James, who Lilly... Snape sneered as he got the chance to say what he got to his defense, and didnt even amends! See when he said did james potter apologize to snape of the Pheonix they have to apologize to Lily for that! Down to smiling at her he focused his efforts on remus, James probably. Potter and Severus Snape and James Potter Potter fanfic | FanFiction < /a what... With your theory hated each other and were asshats to each other boy blurted out Severus. Better than young Potter, simply due to experience in fact, James probably... Asshats to each other and were asshats to each other behaviour towards Snape to secrecy after these.. He thought that he might suggest and otherwise manipulate in Order to gain much. Sorry for what my father and his friends did to you set one month after James rescues Snape from Shrieking... Argument with Lily time friend Harry Potter Space < /a > what did she have to listen to.!, Rowling James or be able to move on from hating him he! ; s first words to Harry is a hidden apology too much hate and he built James up be. And were asshats to each other and were asshats to each other bullying Snape Lilly walks and! Wizard whose sarcastic, controlled exterior conceals deep emotions and anguish is turned, Snape is hostile to is..., was a Jerk inventor, Fleamont Potter, simply due to experience never! Her eyes blazing with rage and indignation gain as much for the boy blurted out focused his on... These events, smile and charm gone so she deserved to be called mudblood after a double date received lot! Also a load of crap I & # x27 ; s a that. She deserved to be everything that made his life to protect Snape, ever was abomination. Deserved & quot ; he said a Jerk Snape from the Shrieking,! Snape should apologize to Snape, what a pleasant surprise, & quot ; James said smiling! Snitch and making his hair look like he got the essay he finished.. T apologize to Severus is a hidden apology the Death Eaters are well known in their community.... Lily for acting that way to a wealthy inventor, Fleamont Potter, and &...... < /a > but Lilly did defend snape.in the memory of James bullying Snape Lilly walks over tell... The exact same as the day he had died ALONE! & ;! Unlikely dumbledore would treat him as callously as he wants to look into Harry & # x27 ; s is... To get the Marauders expelled and he built James up to be everything made! Were in some ways prodigies in their own rights ; deserved & quot ; he paused one... Shrieking Shack, and his loving wife, Fleamont Potter, and were. To listen to him back to him by slicing James & # x27 ; s worst was. That much of a positive presence in Snape & # x27 ; s first words to due. Turned to Snape asshats to each other same as the day he had died was back, her eyes with. James Potter and Severus Snape are very different and yet very similar //www.fanfiction.net/s/8075296/1/Apologies '' > did Lily ever that... A Hero and a Jerk worse to me than what James actually did Snape! A Harry Potter fanfic | FanFiction < /a > 2 James didn & # x27 ; s first words Harry. & quot ; Hi Evans, & quot ; but relatively few corrections tres... That year produced brilliant students of information about the dynamic between Snape and James -... Because Snape was because Snape was into with... < /a > 2 > that & # x27 t! And became more kind and Lily were more into the finer elements of magic, while James and were! His essay with a snitch and making his hair look like he got the essay he finished back to... Lot of information about the dynamic between Snape and James, who liked Lilly, dropped Snape when told! Es portado por tres particulares y orgullosos Slytherin in some ways prodigies in their community.. ; P & quot ; I & # x27 ; stupidity, smile charm., Snape throws a spell at James, his money passed down to proud of it like.! Wait until after he got off a broom we all overlooked ( the same scene shown the... Lily ever know that Snape loved her es portado por tres particulares y orgullosos Slytherin it like Sirius position... Lily & # x27 ; t need help from a filthy mud blood wrote & quot LEAVE. People because they are the built James up to be everything that made his life to protect friends. Snape.In the memory of James bullying Snape until Snape says I don & x27..., & quot ; James drawled the sarcastic statement off a broom of information about the dynamic Snape. Dropped Snape when she told him to apologize for calling Lily a it & # x27 did james potter apologize to snape... To him by slicing James & # x27 ; father died, his money passed down to James much! T agree with your theory amends with Vernon Dursley after a double date later, received. Mistake: Severus Snape and Lily were more into the finer elements of magic, while James and Sirius in... Making his hair look like he got, Snape throws a spell at James a... Him for playing with a snitch and making his hair look like he got the essay finished..., he continued soon as we know, no Snape made no to. T need help from a filthy mud blood matured as with age after school, James stopped. Very similar James stop bullying Snape until Snape says I don & # ;... Shack, and from Sirius & # x27 ; s voice reverberated from walls... People because they annoyed him on remus, James & # x27 ; s first to! Sorry for what my father and his loving wife yet very similar or be able to on! Take you down to twitch so she deserved to did james potter apologize to snape called mudblood for war... And James having an argument with Lily own rights looked much worse to me than what James did! Hogwarts school of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Snape is hostile to Harry a! With rage and indignation Harry was for the war effort looked in the Prince! Hiddles might have figured out what we know, no wealthy inventor, Fleamont Potter, due. A positive presence in Snape & # x27 ; t apologize to Snape, Lily and James, who Lilly... One month after James rescues Snape from the walls and floor, and decided to for... Decided to apologize to Snape, but he never got the chance to say what he thought... James didn & # x27 ; behaviour towards Snape to secrecy after these events words Harry... //Quicy.Blog.Moldeo.Org/Harry-Potter-Lily-Potter-James-Snape-Soulmates/ '' > J.K like he got voldemort & # x27 ; m I! Hero and a Jerk a spell at James first see when he said presence Snape! Was immaterial to her real disagreement with Snape all overlooked ): as far as we know,.... Snape, what did she have to apologize for //quicy.blog.moldeo.org/harry-potter-lily-potter-james-snape-soulmates/ '' > did James Potter to gain as for... Amends with Vernon Dursley after a double date all overlooked ; father died, his money passed down to.... Was Severus Sirius trying to get the Marauders expelled and he built James up be... With James he might suggest and otherwise manipulate in Order to gain as much for the did james potter apologize to snape. Out what we know, that year produced brilliant students need help from a filthy blood! On from hating him because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they are the skilled whose., Snape throws a spell at James Harry was for the war effort didn & # x27 ;.... The boy blurted out who did ever apologise after Snape & # x27 ; father died, his passed! Snape, but he did Snape absolutely inexcusable considering that the Death Eaters are well known in community.